In his Judgment of the 11th September 1997, at C on page 12, Mr Recorder Barnes says:

[The non-medical expert instructed on behalf of the Plaintiff] agreed that in 1990 the literature from the Health & Safety Executive did not specifically draw attention to any link between upper limb disorders and VDU operators, and I have that report provided to me. Similarly, he said that in the 1983 report from the Health & Safety Executive there was again no specific link drawn between VDU operators and upper limb disorders .....

At D on page 38 of the Judgment, Mr Recorder Barnes says:

It is right to say that [the Ergonomics Expert instructed on behalf to the Defendant] says from about 1985 onwards .... it was widely appreciated that particularly high risks were run by operators whose work involved intense keyboard activity, and that equipment constraints on posture were associated with increased risks. That is the view of an expert in these matters, but neither of the Health & Safety Executive reports refer to that problem. It does not appear that any complaints were ever addressed to management about the VDU or the key input factor, and I do not find that it was foreseeable at the time with which I am concerned that the employer should have foreseen a risk of injury. What might have been foreseen by an expert would not necessarily have been reasonably foreseen by an employer.

V1.01